.
Feedback

Vice Mayor Still Wants A's to Move to Fremont

Anu Natarajan noted her will to revisit the idea of bringing the MLB team to the Tri-Cities at a recent Fremont City Council meeting.

At least one city leader has not given up on the hope to bring the A's to Fremont, according to media reports.

The Fremont Argus reported that Fremont Vice Mayor Anu Natarajan mentioned the A's while discussing the significance of creating a unique anchor for the city's proposed downtown area at the Fremont City Council's Feb. 12 meeting.

According to the Argus, A's co-owner Lew Wolff was vocal about moving the Athletics into Fremont between 2006 and 2009, but started working on moving the A's to San Jose after the housing market crashed and residents expressed opposition, The Argus reported.

While The Argus reported that city officials have not discussed the possibility with A's personnel, Natarajan said the A's plans to move to the South Bay seemed to have been stalled and that "she would like to revisit the idea.

"If nothing is happening in San Jose, I believe Fremont needs to be at the table, even if the chance is remote," Natarajan told the Argus.

Wolff told The Argus on Friday that his focus is still on the South Bay.

Click here to read the full report from The Argus.

Would you want the A's to move to the Tri-Cities? Share your thoughts in our comments section below.

Bruce MacNaughton February 20, 2013 at 05:16 pm
What a bad idea. Look all over the U.S. the towns where professional sports teams moved to: The Dallas Cowboys to Irving, then Arlington. The NY Giants and Jets to the Meadowlands. The New England Patriots in Foxboro. I'm listing football teams because in baseball the only teams that don't play in their named city are the Tampa Bay Devil Rays (St. Petersburg), the NY Mets (Flushing NY). and the Texas Rangers (Arlington).
Note that none of those cities are famous or considered major-league cities. What do they get - periodic traffic jams that interfere with their citizens' lives, episodic low-paying jobs, leftover trash from game days, more drunken drivers, and some overtime for their police force. Why in the world would anyone want to be a major league city's whipping boy?
Tim February 20, 2013 at 07:19 pm
The New York Mets do play within their named city. Flushing, NY is in the Borough of Queens which is within the city limits of NYC. Likewise, the New York Yankees and Yankee Stadium are in the Borough of The Bronx; also within NYC limits. The last NY team to be located in Manhattan was the NY Giants at the Polo Grounds (technically the Mets from 1962-1963 as well). New York certainly is a "major-league" city. It's the largest media market in the nation. The other thing these teams bring to their cities that you don't mention is TAX REVENUE. It's a greater benefit to the city than a detriment.
Bruce MacNaughton February 20, 2013 at 10:59 pm
Fair enough on Flushing - I'll live and learn. But I didn't mention the Yankees because I understoodd that the Bronx, as in the Bronx Bombers, are part of NYC.
I would never imply that NYC is not a major-league city. The point is that all the little suburbs that took on major league teams (Meadowlands, Foxboro, Irving, Arlington) don't become major league cities. They just become places that major league cities drop their problems on. Just what tax revenues would the stadium bring in that rational development of the land wouldn't bring in? The land is owned by ProLogis, a private real estate company. They propose a Santana Row-like development to help finance the stadium. Like shops and residents want to be next to a place that makes it impossible to come and go 1/3 of the time? The local city gets about 17% (average) of property taxes. They get 3/4 of cent of the sales tax on each dollar. I haven't done the math, but a high-end shopping center like Santana Row and over 3000 homes have to come pretty close to matching, or exceeding, the revenue from a stadium. And it increases the value of the surrounding property rather than decreasing it.
Tim February 21, 2013 at 01:13 am
All I have to do is point out what AT&T Park has done for the China Basin area of SF. Why don't you ask some of the local businesses there how they feel about the Giants? That area was a shit hole before the Giants (with their OWN money I might add) built AT&T Park. Now, it's completely cleaned up and rents in the area are astronomical.
It's true in the case of the Patriots that Gillette is secluded without and major development nearby. Part of that is that a football stadium hosts 8 games a season whereas baseball 81. The other part is that it's just a rural-suburban spot it was built. I would argue that an appropriate spot in Fremont would do for it what AT&T did to China Basin. Obviously if the A's got a home south of Automall near the bay on a large undeveloped area, it wouldn't have the same effect. More and more, we see new baseball stadiums being built in downtown areas. The new Nationals ballpark in Washington is another great success story.
migueld February 21, 2013 at 01:50 am
No - China Basin was booming long before AT&T was a glimmer owing, in large measure to the boom in internet office space. But never mind those facts . . .
migueld February 21, 2013 at 01:53 am
"According to the Argus, A's co-owner Lew Wolff was vocal about moving the Athletics into Fremont between 2006 and 2009, but started working on moving the A's to San Jose after the housing market crashed and residents expressed opposition, The Argus Reported" - what terrible coverage. The facts are that in addition to the fall-off in available financing and a handful of residents opposing this thing, major business interests in the area opposed the proposal. . . . but, let's not include that in your coverage.
Nick February 21, 2013 at 09:57 pm
Internet boom started in 1997 - 2000. The park was already approved for construction in 1996. Real estate in the area jumped once the ballpark was approved. Pac Bell Park did more for the area there, than the Internet boom. No way the Giants could have afforded that land IF the internet boom was in fact responsible for bringing retailers to China Basin. The area was better known for early morning flower supplies and wedding dresses and a dumped body of a woman. Pac Bell and the Giants entered into an agreement sometime in 1995/96 on naming rights, I believe it was a 24 year deal.
Bruce MacNaughton February 22, 2013 at 03:47 pm
My point stands - AT&T Park didn't make SF a major league city - it already was a major league city. And the reasons for China Basin's resurgence are many. It's at the end of the line for the CalTrain, the new street car system goes south from there, real estate in the rest of SF was expensive and there was room to build there. SOMA became a cool place for the younger people in SF because it was cheaper and mass transit was easily available. There's not really much retail around there - but there are plenty of bars cashing in on the crowds.
And I could point out that Candlestick Park has not exactly revitalized the area. It's not as simple as building a stadium and things get good. If I were a business on Automall Parkway I wouldn't want a stadium to make it hard for my customers to shop on game days. If I were a bar or restaurant I might have a different perspective though.
Rob Johnson February 22, 2013 at 03:54 pm
Says the man who didn't know the "Mets" played in NYC.
Nick February 22, 2013 at 05:15 pm
Agreed, SF did not need a ball park to make itself into a major league town. SF was able to support 2 major franchises for more than 50 years. SF is a major metropolis and the Warriors want to cash in on it. They didn't even give Oakland a chance. They know it's where people want to be. Much rather see them throw an arena closer to downtown than the pier....something like the Madison Square Garden of the West.
Bruce MacNaughton February 23, 2013 at 12:04 am
Sorry Rob - I didn't know Flushing was part of NYC. The rest of the points are accurate and support the argument. But I probably deserve a jab for being ignorant on the details of NYC.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Fremont Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something